Study finds that distances from drilling site play major role in risk of groundwater impacts
Homeowners living within 1 km of shale gas wells appear to be at higher risk of having their drinking water contaminated by stray gases, according to a new Duke University-led study.
Duke scientists analyzed 141 drinking water samples from private water wells across northeastern Pennsylvania's gas-rich Marcellus shale basin. Their study documented not only higher methane concentrations in drinking water within 1 km of shale gas drilling — which past studies have shown — but higher ethane and propane concentrations as well.
Methane concentrations were six times higher and ethane concentrations were 23 times higher at homes within 1 km of a shale gas well. Propane was detected in 10 samples, all of them from homes within 1 km of drilling.
"The methane, ethane and propane data, and new evidence from hydrocarbon and helium isotopes, all suggest that drilling has affected some homeowners' water," said Robert B. Jackson, professor of environmental sciences at Duke's Nicholas School of the Environment. "In a minority of cases, the gas even looks Marcellus-like, probably caused by faulty well construction."
The ethane and propane contamination data are "new and hard to refute," Jackson said. "There is no biological source of ethane and propane in the region and Marcellus gas is high in both, and higher in concentration than the Upper Devonian gas found in between."
The team examined which factors might explain their results, including topography, distance to gas wells and distance to geologic features. "Distance to gas wells was, by far, the most significant factor influencing gases in the drinking water we sampled," Jackson said.
The peer-reviewed findings appeared in the online Early Edition of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Hydraulic fracturing, also called hydrofracking or fracking, involves pumping water, sand and chemicals deep underground into horizontal gas wells at high pressure to crack open hydrocarbon-rich shale and extract natural gas. Accelerated shale gas drilling and hydrofracking in recent years has fueled concerns about contamination in nearby drinking water supplies.
Two previous peer-reviewed studies by Duke scientists found direct evidence of methane contamination in water wells near shale gas drilling sites in northeastern Pennsylvania, as well as possible connectivity between deep brines and shallow aquifers. A third study conducted with U.S. Geological Survey scientists found no evidence of drinking water contamination from shale gas production in Arkansas. None of the studies have found evidence of contamination by fracking fluids.
"Our studies demonstrate that distances from drilling sites, as well as variations in local and regional geology, play major roles in determining the possible risk of groundwater impacts from shale gas development," said Avner Vengosh, professor of geochemistry and water quality at Duke's Nicholas School. "As such, they must be taken into consideration before drilling begins."